Though her performance during Rolling Stones tribute night garnered her first positive reviews since audition week, Brown received the lowest votes of the night, behind Tim Urban and Paige Miles.
The church teacher had a chance to sing for a save but her pitchy rendition of Brandi Carlile's "The Story" only solidified the judges' decision.
During Idol auditions, Brown brought smiles to the judges faces with her jazzy version of "Over the Rainbow," but since then her performances have been lackluster.
The shy contestant who was prodded "like a cow" by her mother to audition could have used some maternal pressure on stage.
Read More → American Idol 2010 : Lacey Brown is voted off as Kesha
